Stuart and Martin County · City of Stuart
Fairfield Inn site, 255 SW 6th St, Stuart: hotel rezoning back after a court ruling
Stuart denied rezoning a 0.33-acre piece of the old funeral home site at 255 SW 6th Street for a hotel in 2025. A judge sent it back, and the City Commission reheard it on 2026-09-28. That outcome isn't posted yet.
255 SW 6th Street, Stuart, FL (part of 505 SW Federal Highway) on the map
Where it stands
The City Commission reheard this on 2026-09-28. The result isn't public yet, because the minutes haven't been posted. We'll update this page when they are.
How it got here:
- Denied in February 2025. On second reading, a motion to approve died without a second, and the commission voted to deny.
- The owner went to court. On 2025-12-19 a circuit judge found the city "departed from the essential requirements of law" and sent the case back for a new hearing.
- Delayed once. The rehearing was set for 2026-04-13 and postponed at the applicant's request.
What's proposed
Rezone a 0.33-acre piece of the old funeral home site, at 255 SW 6th Street, from Urban Waterfront to Urban Highway, so the whole property falls in one zoning district. The owner says the goal is a hotel.
- Hotels are allowed in both districts. Staff say the rezoning mainly fixes conflicting parking rules between the two.
- No hotel plan is attached. There's no site plan, room count or height in this request.
Why it matters to neighbors
- Homes back onto the property. At earlier hearings, residents asked for buffers and raised lighting, noise and where the dumpster goes.
What city staff said
Approve. Every board that has heard it recommended approval: the Local Planning Agency (unanimous, 2025-01-16) and the Community Redevelopment Board (unanimous, 2025-02-04).
Who's behind it
- Applicant and owner: Polk Street Hotels, Inc.
- Agent: Law Offices of Marc R. Gaylord, P.A.
Hearings
| Board | Date | Outcome |
|---|---|---|
| Local Planning Agency | 2025-01-16 | Recommended approval, unanimous |
| City Commission, first reading | 2025-01-27 | Approved, unanimous |
| Community Redevelopment Board | 2025-02-04 | Recommended approval, unanimous |
| City Commission, second reading | 2025-02-10 | Denied |
| Circuit Court | 2025-12-19 | Denial overturned, sent back for a new hearing |
| City Commission | 2026-04-13 | Postponed at the applicant's request |
| City Commission, rehearing | 2026-09-28 | Not yet recorded |
Sources
Written from the staff report, the ordinance and past minutes. Last checked 2026-10-21.
What's Going Up Here is independent and not affiliated with any government.